Lucid Trading vs TradeDay: Which Prop Firm Is Better in 2026?
In short: TradeDay currently rates higher by Enigma Score. Lucid Trading starts at $75.60 with a 90/10 split; TradeDay starts at $53 with a 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit) split. Code FE applies each firm’s current discount. The full side-by-side on Enigma Score, pricing, drawdown model and payouts follows.
By Steve H — reads every firm’s official rulebook, checks prices and codes daily, and maintains the Enigma Score · Methodology · Editorial policy · Last updated November 1, 2026
| Lucid Trading | TradeDay | |
|---|---|---|
| Enigma Score (firm) | 66/100 (B) | 69/100 (B) |
| Enigma Rating (best plan) | 8.1/10 (Excellent) | 8.3/10 (Excellent) |
| Best plan | LucidDaily EOD (DLL on) 50K · $95.20 all-in | End of Day Evaluation (monthly) 150K · $180 all-in |
| Net first payout | ≈ $2,700 net | ≈ $7,200 net |
| Days to first payout | ≈ 4 trading days | ≈ 6 trading days |
| Pass Ease | 78/100 | 62/100 |
| From (with code) | $75.60 | $53 |
| FundedEnigma code | FE | FE |
| Current discount | 40% off | 55% off |
| Profit split | 90/10 | 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit) |
| Drawdown model | EOD | Intraday or EOD (chosen at purchase); funded sim intraday (Quick Pay) / EOD (Fast Pass) |
| Payouts | Daily (LucidDaily) / 3–5 day cycles | Daily (Quick Pay) |
| Max allocation | $150K | $150K |
| Type | Futures | Futures |
Why each best plan scores the way it does
TradeDay's best plan rates higher (8.3/10 (Excellent)). Reasons come from each plan's own rules and price, judged against plans with the same drawdown type.
Lucid TradingLucidDaily EOD (DLL on) 50K
- +End-of-day drawdown in eval
- +Intraday trailing drawdown once funded, locks at the start balance
- +Higher first-payout return per $ than most plans in this market
- +Bigger usable loss buffer per $ than most plans in this market
- +Up to $75,000 of sim payouts before the move to live (5 accounts)
- +Reviews praise: Fast payouts (10%)
- −Daily loss limit $1,200
- −50% consistency rule in eval
- −$2,100 profit buffer before the first withdrawal
- −Reviews mention: Account blocks / KYC disputes (42%)
- −Reviews mention: Scam accusations (20%)
TradeDayEnd of Day Evaluation (monthly) 150K
- +End-of-day drawdown in eval
- +No daily loss limit
- +Higher first-payout return per $ than most plans in this market
- +Bigger usable loss buffer per $ than most plans in this market
- +Up to $60,000 of sim payouts before the move to live (6 accounts)
- +Reviews praise: Helpful support (12%)
- +Reviews praise: Fast payouts (10%)
- −Intraday trailing drawdown once funded
- −30% consistency rule in eval
- −5 trading days minimum
- −Reviews mention: Scam accusations (5%)
Key differences
- TradeDay is cheaper to start — from $53 vs $75.60 (a $22.60 difference) with code FE.
- Lucid Trading has the higher profit split (90/10 vs 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit)), so you keep more of what you earn.
- Drawdown models differ: Lucid Trading uses EOD, while TradeDay uses Intraday or EOD (chosen at purchase); funded sim intraday (Quick Pay) / EOD (Fast Pass) — often the deciding factor for active traders.
- Payout schedules differ: Lucid Trading — Daily (LucidDaily) / 3–5 day cycles; TradeDay — Daily (Quick Pay).
- TradeDay has the bigger live discount right now — 55% off vs 40%, via code FE.
Our verdict
Simplicity vs seasoning
Both pay daily, and there the similarity ends. Lucid Trading is the simplicity pick: flat 90/10 split, end-of-day drawdown, and no consistency rule — the shortest rulebook in this matchup. TradeDay is the seasoned pick: three years of operating history, a desk-culture setup with Jigsaw and NinjaTrader support, but a tiered split that starts at 50/50 on the first $4,000, intraday drawdown, and a strict 30% consistency requirement.
Bottom line
Choose Lucid if you want maximum keep-rate from the first withdrawal and the freedom of a no-consistency account on EOD drawdown. Choose TradeDay if a longer track record and professional order-flow tooling are worth trading under tighter rules while your split scales up.
Lucid Trading and TradeDay on video
- All Three TradeDay Plans In One Video: Quick Pay Intraday (Paid From Day One, No Buffer, Intraday Drawdown), Quick Pay End Of Day (End-Of-Day Drawdown To Pass, Paid From Day One) And Fast Pass (Pass In 3 Days, End-Of-Day Drawdown Once Funded, 80/20).
Prices and rules in this video are as of 2026-10-07 and may have changed — the current prices on this page were verified 2026-11-01.
- TradeDay Fast Pass, Explained End To End — And Rated.
- Pass In As Few As 3 Days, Then An End-Of-Day Drawdown Once Funded And An 80/20 Split From The First Payout.
- 1/10, Strong) Against Its Closest Rival (Topstep Combine 50K (No Activation Fee)).
Prices and rules in this video are as of 2026-10-07 and may have changed — the current prices on this page were verified 2026-11-01.
Which should you choose?
Choose Lucid Trading if you want a higher profit split (90/10).
Choose TradeDay if you want a lower entry cost, a bigger current discount (55% off) and a higher overall Enigma Score.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Lucid Trading or TradeDay better?
- By the Enigma Score, TradeDay rates higher (69/100 (B)). Both list verified pricing and their FundedEnigma affiliate discount — the better choice depends on your priorities (cost, drawdown model, payout speed).
- Which is cheaper, Lucid Trading or TradeDay?
- TradeDay is cheaper to start, from $53 with code FE versus $75.60 for Lucid Trading.
- Which has the higher profit split?
- Lucid Trading offers the higher profit split (90/10) compared with 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit) at TradeDay.
- How do payouts compare?
- Lucid Trading pays out daily (luciddaily) / 3–5 day cycles, while TradeDay pays out daily (quick pay). Check each firm's first-payout rules on its review page before deciding.
- Are there discount codes for Lucid Trading and TradeDay?
- FundedEnigma's current deals — Lucid Trading: code FE (40% off right now); TradeDay: code FE (55% off right now). Discounts change often, so these are updated daily.
Read the full reviews: Lucid Trading · TradeDay · How the Enigma Score works