Lucid Trading vs TradeDay: Which Prop Firm Is Better in 2026?
A side-by-side comparison of Lucid Trading and TradeDay on the FundedEnigma Score, pricing, profit split, drawdown model and payouts. TradeDay currently rates higher by Enigma Score. Code FE applies Lucid Trading’s discount and Fundify applies TradeDay’s.
Reviewed by the FundedEnigma Editorial Team · Methodology · Editorial policy · Last updated September 17, 2026
| Lucid Trading | TradeDay | |
|---|---|---|
| Enigma Score (firm) | 66/100 (B) | 69/100 (B) |
| Enigma Rating (best plan) | 8.4/10 (Excellent) | 8.7/10 (Excellent) |
| Best plan | LucidFlex (DLL off) 50K · $87.60 all-in | End of Day Evaluation (monthly) 50K · $78.75 all-in |
| Net first payout | ≈ $1,800 net | ≈ $2,400 net |
| Days to first payout | ≈ 7 trading days | ≈ 6 trading days |
| Pass Ease | 81/100 | 66/100 |
| From (with code) | $87.60 | $58.95 |
| FundedEnigma code | FE | Fundify |
| Current discount | 40% off | 55% off |
| Profit split | 90/10 | 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit) |
| Drawdown model | EOD | Intraday or EOD (chosen at purchase); funded sim intraday (Quick Pay) / EOD (Fast Pass) |
| Payouts | Daily (LucidDaily) / 3–5 day cycles | Daily (Quick Pay) |
| Max allocation | $150K | $150K |
| Type | futures | futures |
Why each best plan scores the way it does
TradeDay's best plan rates higher (8.7/10 (Excellent)). Reasons come from each plan's own rules and price, judged against plans with the same drawdown type.
Lucid TradingLucidFlex (DLL off) 50K
- +End-of-day drawdown in eval
- +End-of-day drawdown once funded
- +No daily loss limit
- +Higher first-payout return per $ than most end-of-day plans
- +Bigger loss buffer per $ than most peer plans
- +Reviews praise: Fast payouts (18%)
- +Reviews praise: Clear rules (5%)
- −50% consistency rule in eval
- −First payout capped at $2,000
- −Reviews mention: Account blocks / KYC disputes (25%)
- −Reviews mention: Scam accusations (8%)
TradeDayEnd of Day Evaluation (monthly) 50K
- +End-of-day drawdown in eval
- +No daily loss limit
- +Higher first-payout return per $ than most end-of-day plans
- +Bigger loss buffer per $ than most peer plans
- +No per-payout cap
- +Reviews praise: Helpful support (12%)
- +Reviews praise: Fast payouts (10%)
- −Intraday trailing drawdown once funded
- −30% consistency rule in eval
- −5 trading days minimum
- −Reviews mention: Scam accusations (5%)
Key differences
- TradeDay is cheaper to start — from $58.95 vs $87.60 (a $28.65 difference) with code Fundify.
- Lucid Trading has the higher profit split (90/10 vs 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit)), so you keep more of what you earn.
- Drawdown models differ: Lucid Trading uses EOD, while TradeDay uses Intraday or EOD (chosen at purchase); funded sim intraday (Quick Pay) / EOD (Fast Pass) — often the deciding factor for active traders.
- Payout schedules differ: Lucid Trading — Daily (LucidDaily) / 3–5 day cycles; TradeDay — Daily (Quick Pay).
- TradeDay has the bigger live discount right now — 55% off vs 40%, via codes Fundify (TradeDay) / FE (Lucid Trading).
Our verdict
Simplicity vs seasoning
Both pay daily, and there the similarity ends. Lucid Trading is the simplicity pick: flat 90/10 split, end-of-day drawdown, and no consistency rule — the shortest rulebook in this matchup. TradeDay is the seasoned pick: three years of operating history, a desk-culture setup with Jigsaw and NinjaTrader support, but a tiered split that starts at 50/50 on the first $4,000, intraday drawdown, and a strict 30% consistency requirement.
Bottom line
Choose Lucid if you want maximum keep-rate from the first withdrawal and the freedom of a no-consistency account on EOD drawdown. Choose TradeDay if a longer track record and professional order-flow tooling are worth trading under tighter rules while your split scales up.
Which should you choose?
Choose Lucid Trading if you want a higher profit split (90/10).
Choose TradeDay if you want a lower entry cost, a bigger current discount (55% off) and a higher overall Enigma Score.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Lucid Trading or TradeDay better?
- By the Enigma Score, TradeDay rates higher (69/100 (B)). Both list verified pricing and their FundedEnigma affiliate discount — the better choice depends on your priorities (cost, drawdown model, payout speed).
- Which is cheaper, Lucid Trading or TradeDay?
- TradeDay is cheaper to start, from $58.95 with code Fundify versus $87.60 for Lucid Trading.
- Which has the higher profit split?
- Lucid Trading offers the higher profit split (90/10) compared with 80/20 (50/50 until $4K profit) at TradeDay.
- How do payouts compare?
- Lucid Trading pays out daily (luciddaily) / 3–5 day cycles, while TradeDay pays out daily (quick pay). Check each firm's first-payout rules on its review page before deciding.
Read the full reviews: Lucid Trading · TradeDay · How the Enigma Score works