Lucid Trading vs Take Profit Trader: Which Prop Firm Is Better in 2026?
A side-by-side comparison of Lucid Trading and Take Profit Trader on the FundedEnigma Score, pricing, profit split, drawdown model and payouts. Take Profit Trader currently rates higher by Enigma Score. Code FE applies Lucid Trading’s discount and FUNDIFY applies Take Profit Trader’s.
Reviewed by the FundedEnigma Editorial Team · Methodology · Editorial policy · Last updated September 17, 2026
| Lucid Trading | Take Profit Trader | |
|---|---|---|
| Enigma Score (firm) | 66/100 (B) | 70/100 (B+) |
| Enigma Rating (best plan) | 8.4/10 (Excellent) | 8.5/10 (Excellent) |
| Best plan | LucidFlex (DLL off) 50K · $87.60 all-in | Test (1-step) 150K · $294 all-in |
| Net first payout | ≈ $1,800 net | ≈ $7,200 net |
| Days to first payout | ≈ 7 trading days | ≈ 5 trading days |
| Pass Ease | 81/100 | 70/100 |
| From (with code) | $87.60 | $102 |
| FundedEnigma code | FE | FUNDIFY |
| Current discount | 40% off | 40% off |
| Profit split | 90/10 | 80/20 (PRO) · 90/10 (PRO+) |
| Drawdown model | EOD | EOD (test) / Intraday (PRO) / EOD (PRO+) |
| Payouts | Daily (LucidDaily) / 3–5 day cycles | Daily (from day one in PRO) |
| Max allocation | $150K | $150K |
| Type | futures | futures |
Why each best plan scores the way it does
Take Profit Trader's best plan rates higher (8.5/10 (Excellent)). Reasons come from each plan's own rules and price, judged against plans with the same drawdown type.
Lucid TradingLucidFlex (DLL off) 50K
- +End-of-day drawdown in eval
- +End-of-day drawdown once funded
- +No daily loss limit
- +Higher first-payout return per $ than most end-of-day plans
- +Bigger loss buffer per $ than most peer plans
- +Reviews praise: Fast payouts (18%)
- +Reviews praise: Clear rules (5%)
- −50% consistency rule in eval
- −First payout capped at $2,000
- −Reviews mention: Account blocks / KYC disputes (25%)
- −Reviews mention: Scam accusations (8%)
Take Profit TraderTest (1-step) 150K
- +End-of-day drawdown in eval
- +No daily loss limit
- +Higher first-payout return per $ than most end-of-day plans
- +No per-payout cap
- +Reviews praise: Fast payouts (10%)
- −Intraday trailing drawdown once funded
- −50% consistency rule in eval
- −$4,500 profit buffer before the first withdrawal
Key differences
- Lucid Trading is cheaper to start — from $87.60 vs $102 (a $14.40 difference) with code FE.
- Lucid Trading has the higher profit split (90/10 vs 80/20 (PRO) · 90/10 (PRO+)), so you keep more of what you earn.
- Drawdown models differ: Lucid Trading uses EOD, while Take Profit Trader uses EOD (test) / Intraday (PRO) / EOD (PRO+) — often the deciding factor for active traders.
- Payout schedules differ: Lucid Trading — Daily (LucidDaily) / 3–5 day cycles; Take Profit Trader — Daily (from day one in PRO).
Our verdict
Same skeleton, different philosophy
On the surface these two look alike: both are futures firms with end-of-day drawdown and daily payouts. The fork is philosophical. Lucid Trading is the newer, lighter-rules option — a flat 90/10 split with no consistency rule and unusually broad platform support (NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Rithmic, MotiveWave, Quantower). Take Profit Trader is the proven option: five years operating, 7,600+ Trustpilot reviews, but a lower 80/20 split and a consistency requirement.
Bottom line
Choose Lucid if you want to keep more per withdrawal and trade without a consistency rule — accepting a shorter public track record. Choose Take Profit Trader if five years of payout history and six times the review volume are worth giving up ten points of split. If your strategy occasionally produces one outsized day, Lucid's no-consistency policy is the safer home for it.
Which should you choose?
Choose Lucid Trading if you want a lower entry cost and a higher profit split (90/10).
Choose Take Profit Trader if you want a higher overall Enigma Score.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader better?
- By the Enigma Score, Take Profit Trader rates higher (70/100 (B+)). Both list verified pricing and their FundedEnigma affiliate discount — the better choice depends on your priorities (cost, drawdown model, payout speed).
- Which is cheaper, Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader?
- Lucid Trading is cheaper to start, from $87.60 with code FE versus $102 for Take Profit Trader.
- Which has the higher profit split?
- Lucid Trading offers the higher profit split (90/10) compared with 80/20 (PRO) · 90/10 (PRO+) at Take Profit Trader.
- How do payouts compare?
- Lucid Trading pays out daily (luciddaily) / 3–5 day cycles, while Take Profit Trader pays out daily (from day one in pro). Check each firm's first-payout rules on its review page before deciding.
Read the full reviews: Lucid Trading · Take Profit Trader · How the Enigma Score works